2019
- Outstanding Production: Heathers: The Musical
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical: Megan Iannone as Veronica Sawyer
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical: Jessie Rathbun as Veronica Sawyer
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical: Nick Rogers as Jason "J.D." Dean
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical: Alysa Carpenter as Heather Chandler
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical: Beth Noone as Heather Chandler
- Outstanding Supporting Performance (Junior): Kyra Archuleta as Genie
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Sam Evins as Shrek
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Zoe Howell as Fiona
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Gabe Legg as Donkey
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical: Ian Spillman as Jason "J.D." Dean
- Outstanding Supporting Performance (Junior, Nominee): Savannah Craig as Jasmine
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Tristan Collins as Lord Farquaad
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Zoe Howell as Heather Duke
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Tracy Johnson as Heather McNamara
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Sophie Klechka as Martha Dunstock
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Adelaide Otis as Heather Duke
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Delaney Sweeney as Heather McNamara
- Outstanding Featured Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Jewel Garrick as Ms. Fleming
- Outstanding Featured Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Summer Marquis as Ms. Fleming
- Outstanding Featured Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Micah Oren as Ram's Dad
- Outstanding Ensemble (Nominee): Heathers: The Musical
- Outstanding Ensemble (Junior, Nominee): Aladdin Jr.
- Outstanding Direction (Nominee): Ty Eatherton for Heathers: The Musical
2018
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical: Nick Rogers as William Barfee*
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical: Micah Oren as King Arthur
- Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Musical: Gracyn Trautmann as Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre*
- Outstanding Ensemble: The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee*
- Outstanding Ensemble: Spamalot
- Outstanding Direction: Parrish Salyers for The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee*
- Outstanding Production (Nominee): The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee*
- Outstanding Production (Nominee): Spamalot
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Alysa Carpenter as Rona Lisa Peretti*
- Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical (Nominee): Erika Harper as Olive Ostrovsky*
- Outstanding Costume Design (Nominee): Isley Verbonitz for Spamalot
- Outstanding Musical Direction (Nominee): Mitch Samu for Spamalot
- Outstanding Direction (Nominee): Barb Dignan for Spamalot
2017
- Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical: Sam Evins as Dewey Finn
- Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical: Kaitlin Miller as Rosalie Mullins
- Outstanding Supporting Actress: Delaney Sweeney as Summer Hathaway
- Outstanding Featured Actor: Zane Zakroff as Zack Mooneyham
- Outstanding Featured Actor: Cameron Geoffrion as Lawrence
- Outstanding Musical Direction (Nominee): Mitch Samu
2016/2017 Freddie G. Fellowship: Laurilea McDaniel, FRTC Executive Director
- 2014 Music Theatre International: MTI BROADWAY JUNIOR SCHOOL OF EXCELLENCE, Legally Blonde The Musical Jr.